real estate homes in a suburb

“Swap ’Til You Drop”: What Real Estate Investors Should Know About 1031 Exchanges

Aldrich Wealth LP

Consider this scenario: An investor buys an apartment building for $2 million, then sells it for $5 million years later. While they’ve made a tidy profit, it could be reduced by as much as $1 million in state and federal taxes.

With a 1031 exchange, however, the investor could defer those taxes, potentially for decades. Under the right circumstances, they could even pass the property to heirs without ever paying taxes at all.

Sometimes known as a like-kind exchange or a Starker exchange, 1031 exchanges can be a powerful tool for real estate investors. But the rules around them are strict, and there is little margin for error.

Following is a look at the promises—and pitfalls—of 1031 exchanges.

1031 Exchange Basics

A 1031 exchange lets real estate investors sell property and defer the tax bill, provided they reinvest the proceeds into a “like-kind” property. The gain rolls over into the new property, and the money they would have paid in taxes stays invested. 

What Is a “Like-Kind” Property? 

Nearly any real estate held for investment or business use qualifies, and the properties don’t have to be the same type. Raw land can be exchanged for an apartment building, for example, or an office building for a retail center.  

Primary residences, vacation homes used mostly for personal purposes, and fix-and-flips do not qualify. 

Swap ’Til You Drop 

Investors can exchange properties repeatedly, deferring gains each time. If the final property is held until death, heirs generally inherit it at its current market value, known as a “stepped-up basis,” which can eliminate the deferred gain entirely. Many families use 1031 exchanges as an estate planning tool as well as a tax strategy. 

The Devil Is in the Details

While 1031s are powerful, they are also complicated, and mistakes can be costly. Following are some of the technicalities that can trip investors up: 

The Qualified Intermediary Requirement 

To begin with, the investor cannot receive or control the sale proceeds, even briefly, without risking disqualification. Instead, a qualified intermediary (QI) holds the funds and handles the exchange paperwork. 

Strict Deadlines 

The investor must identify potential replacement properties in writing within 45 calendar days. The purchase must then close within 180 days or by that year’s tax return due date, whichever comes first. For late-year sales, it may be necessary to file an extension. 

Identification Rules  

Because deals can fall through, investors are advised to identify more than one property. Identification must follow one of three rules: 

  • Three-property rule: Up to three properties of any value. 
  • 200% rule: Any number of properties, as long as their combined value is no more than twice that of the property sold. 
  • 95% rule: Any number of properties, as long as the investor buys at least 95% of the total value identified. 
State Tax Considerations 

State treatment of 1031 exchanges varies. Some states track deferred gain when the replacement property is out of state. They may require annual filings and collect the tax when that property is eventually sold. Moving to a state without an income tax doesn’t necessarily end the original state’s claim. 

Taxable “Boot” 

Anything received that isn’t like-kind property, such as cash taken out of the deal or certain reductions in mortgage debt, is called ‘boot’ and may trigger a tax liability. However, receiving boot does not make the entire exchange taxable. Generally, recognized gain is limited to the lesser of the realized gain or the boot received, subject to applicable tax rules. 

Depreciation Recapture (§1245) 

Since 2018, only real property qualifies for a 1031 exchange. This can create complications for investors who have used cost segregation, a strategy that accelerates depreciation by classifying certain building components, such as appliances and carpeting, as personal property. While personal property generally does not qualify for 1031 treatment, certain §1245 assets may still qualify as real property under state law. While certain property, like storage units for example, are considered 1245 property, could be still be considered real property for the purpose’s of 1031 exchanges under state law. 

Related Party Restrictions 

When property is exchanged with a family member or an entity the investor controls, both parties generally must hold their properties for two years. Otherwise, the tax deferral can be lost. 

Expanding Your Options

Several structures and investment vehicles can give investors more flexibility in timing, property choice, and long-term strategy when using 1031 exchanges. 

Qualified Exchange Accommodation Arrangements (QEAAs) 

Not all 1031 exchanges follow the standard sell-first, buy-later sequence. In a reverse exchange, investors can arrange to acquire the replacement property before selling the relinquished property. However, these transactions generally require an Exchange Accommodation Titleholder (EAT) to temporarily hold title to the property. Investors cannot simply purchase the replacement property themselves and sell their existing property within 180 days to qualify for tax deferral. Investors may also buy and sell exchanged properties on the same day. 

Investors also have the option of a build-to-suit exchange, in which exchange funds are used to build on or improve the replacement property.  To count toward the exchange value, improvements must be completed and in place before the replacement property is transferred to the investor, within the applicable 180-day exchange period. Consider that QEAAs involve higher costs, strict deadlines, financing challenges, and potential loss of tax-deferral benefits.  

Delaware Statutory Trusts (DSTs) 

DSTs are fractional interests in large, professionally managed properties. Because the IRS treats them as like-kind property, investors often use them in a 1031 exchange to: 

  • Meet deadlines: DST interests can usually be purchased quickly, which helps when a deadline is approaching. 
  • Identify a backup: A DST can serve as a fallback if a primary purchase falls through. 
  • Avoid boot: Leftover proceeds can go into a DST instead of being received as taxable cash. 
  • Step back from management: Investors can stay in real estate without having to manage property themselves. 
721 Exchanges (UPREITs) 

After a 1031 exchange, investors may be able to use a separate transaction under §721 to contribute real estate to an operating partnership associated with an umbrella partnership real estate investment trust (UPREIT). In return, investors receive operating partnership units rather than REIT shares directly. In some structures, an investor first exchanges into a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST), whose property may later be contributed to the UPREIT’s operating partnership. While this strategy can provide access to a diversified real estate portfolio and continued tax deferral, it is subject to additional requirements. Deferred gains may become taxable if the partnership units are subsequently sold or redeemed. 

It is important to note that UPREITs and DSTs involve limited liquidity, reduced investor control, higher fees, real estate market risks, and potential loss of tax-deferral benefits. 

Planning Ahead for a Successful 1031 Exchange

A 1031 exchange can be an effective way to defer taxes and build long-term wealth. But strict deadlines, technical rules, and varying state requirements leave little room for error, making professional guidance essential.  

Curious if a 1031 exchange is right for you? Talk to your Aldrich wealth advisor or CPA. They can help you decide whether an exchange fits your broader goals and work with a qualified intermediary to keep the process on track. 

Connect with us
Related Articles
Agentic AI: What Investors Should Know
Q3 2026 Market Commentary + Q4 Outlook

Looking for support or have a question?

Contact us to speak with one of our advisors.

[gravityform id="2" title="false" description="false" ajax="true"]